Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations
Edmond v. Goldsmith: Are Roadblocks Used to Catch Drug Offenders Constitutional?
See on the mapAbstract
I. INTRODUCrION"The Fourth Amendment imposes limits on search-and-seizure powers in order to prevent arbitrary and oppressive interference by enforcement officials with the privacy and personal security of individuals."' Over the last several decades, the United States Supreme Court has carved out several exceptions to the protections provided by the Fourth Amendment.These exceptions include roadblocks used to monitor the influx of illegal immigrants, 2 roadblocks used to review persons' license and registration, 3 and roadblocks used to monitor people who may be driving under the influence of alcohol. 4 At first glance, it may seem as if the Court has drawn a bright-line rule with regard to the constitutionality of roadblocks.Instead, a web of inconsistency has been woven among the federal and state courts to determine whether roadblocks used to apprehend drug offenders are consistent with the Fourth Amendment.On July 7, 1999, the Seventh Circuit, in Edmond v. Goldsmith 6 added another intricate layer to the web of confusion.In this case, the court held that the roadblocks used by the City of Indianapolis to apprehend drug offenders violated the Fourth Amendment As a result of the split between the federal and state courts, the United States Supreme Court has granted certiorari, and will review this case October 3, 2000.8This Note, beginning with Part II, will give a summary of the facts in Edmond.Part III will outline the background of the law leading up to (2000).