arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science

Lab coats in Hollywood: Science, scientists, and cinema

Thomas Parham

· Science Education

See on the map

Abstract

by David A. Kirby. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, USA, 2011. xiv + 265 pp. ISBN 978-0-2620-1478-6. In Lab Coats in Hollywood, science communication scholar David Kirby challenges and ultimately rejects the culturally accepted notion of cinematic science consultants being Hollywood's most fastidious fact-checkers. Instead, armed with an impressive array of historical research and first-hand accounts from active consultants, Kirby reveals a much deeper relationship between science consultants and filmmakers. As would be expected of any book exploring cinematic science, Lab Coats in Hollywood provides a rich discussion of how film's “naturalizing effect” (p. 33) can dramatically affect public perceptions of scientific phenomena and the “cultural meanings” of science (p. 15). However, what makes Kirby's analysis unique is its thorough examination of the interplay between scientific and cinematic cultures from the perspectives of those who actively seek to bridge the gap. This behind-the-scenes approach has the pleasant side effect of making the Lab Coats in Hollywood highly engaging and culturally relevant, especially for sci-fi fans who have seen the numerous exemplars of “movie science” (p. 228). Kirby has peppered throughout the book. Although clearly written for a broad audience, Lab Coats in Hollywood may provide science educators with a particularly interesting case study of science as a social and cultural endeavor. Kirby opens his discussion of cinematic science by retreading some familiar ground, albeit in somewhat unfamiliar terms. For example, Kirby discusses the potential for films to serve as “virtual witnessing technologies” (p. 24). According to Kirby, although notable scientists may claim that direct perception of evidence (i.e., “witnessing”) is the only means by which to generate new scientific knowledge, the fact that the vast majority of scientists may not have direct access to the phenomena themselves has lead modern science to accept the abstract perception, or indirect witnessing, of natural phenomena (e.g., through peer-reviewed publication) as reliable. Therefore, in Kirby's view, a filmic context effectively “blurs the boundaries between indirect witnessing and direct witnessing” (p. 27) by offering audiences direct access to phenomena but framing those phenomena in a highly abstracted or entirely fictionalized world (the “diegesis” or filmic universe). Furthermore, Kirby asserts that a filmic context can very effectively “naturalize” images (p. 33) and that films must impose truth claims upon scientific depictions out of a necessity to propel the narrative (p. 28). This naturalizing effect and the resultant perceptions of truth gives films a considerable power to impact and persuade their audiences. The importance of science consultants is in helping filmmakers craft images and narratives that convey the excitement of scientific research or communicate a sense of awe about the natural world … it is crucial for a science consultant to identify those aspects of scientific knowledge that will significantly impact the cultural meanings of science.” (p. 117) Reflecting this perspective, the majority of Lab Coats is dedicated to exploring ways in which consultants can (and do) work with filmmakers in a symbiotic manner rather than antagonistically insisting upon absolute accuracy, which Kirby argues is an ambiguous concept to filmmakers and ultimately impossible due to filmmaking constraints. During his exploration of the social and political dynamics driving consultant–filmmaker relationships, Kirby concludes that the collaboration is often most productive when scientists use their specialized expertise in logical reasoning and “knowing what we do not know” (p. 121) to define the boundaries of plausibility within which filmmakers may apply their own creative expertise. He notes, however, that the idea of uncertainty, while occasionally useful to filmmakers and an ever-present element of scientific culture, may als

More like this