Social Sciences · Law
Come Hell or High Water: Reexamining the Takings Clause in a Climate Changed Future
See on the mapAbstract
I. INTRODUCTION By the end of this century climate change will cause a global rise in sea level that is unprecedented in American history. Thousands of square miles of land, and several major cities, are at risk of becoming submerged under ocean waters. (1) This large-scale sea level rise will cause, a collision between two fundamental doctrines of property law--the public trust doctrine and the takings clause of the Fifth Amendment. The public trust doctrine will require the states to assert control over vast amounts of private lands that are submerged by the ocean and have become tidal lands and waters subject to the public trust. Yet, if this act is considered a taking it may impose a significant financial burden on the states to provide adequate compensation, and perhaps even be impracticable given the substantial amounts of land and large number of private property owners threatened by large-scale sea level rise. This large-scale sea level rise caused by climate change will present a new and unique challenge to current takings jurisprudence. For the past century, many of the most difficult and contentious issues arising out of the takings clause involved determining whether a government regulation of private property constituted a taking. (2) Traditionally, the state action implicated by climate change and large-scale sea level rise--where the government either takes title to private land or subjects it to the public trust--has been considered an undisputed taking that requires compensation. (3) While this per se takings rule is one of the most stable and uncontroversial aspects of current takings jurisprudence, (4) the unprecedented nature of large-scale sea level rise caused by climate change requires a reexamination of whether it should always be a taking any time the government appropriates or occupies private land. This Note examines how climate change and the resulting sea level rise will place new tensions on the interaction of the public trust doctrine and the takings clause. It argues that it should not be considered a taking when a state takes title or asserts control over private lands submerged due to climate change and large-scale sea level rise, even if the government takes the entire property interest of a private property owner. Part II explains the basics of climate change and sea level rise. Part III explores the public trust doctrine as it applies to coastal lands and waters, the common law doctrine of erosion and accretion, and the takings clause. Part IV considers the tension that climate change will create between the public trust doctrine and the takings clause. Finally, Part V reexamines the takings clause in light of our climate changed future and argues for a narrow exception to the per se possessory takings rule. II. CLIMATE CHANGE AND SEA LEVEL RISE A. The Basics of Climate Change The concentration of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere has increased significantly since the 18th century and the dawning of the industrial revolution. (5) The four principal greenhouse gases emitted by anthropogenic activities are carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide and halocarbons. (6) The atmospheric concentration of carbon dioxide has increased from a pre-industrial value of 280 ppm (parts per million) to 379 ppm in 2005, primarily because of the burning of fossil fuels and changes in land use. (7) The atmospheric concentrations of methane and nitrous oxide have similarly increased, mainly due to increased agriculture. (8) The current atmospheric concentrations of these greenhouse gases now far exceed the atmospheric concentration levels measured in ice cores spanning thousands of years. (9) This increase in the atmospheric concentration of greenhouse gases alters the energy balance of the climate system by trapping heat near the Earth's surface. (10) As a result, there has been an unequivocal warming of the Earth. (11) The average global surface temperature today is 0. …