Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations
What Does it Take to Make a Federal System? On Constitutional Entrenchment, Separate Spheres, and Identity
See on the mapAbstract
When I took the introductory Constitutional Law course in the spring of 1992, federalism was the subject of three or four days at most, most of them spent on the dormant Commerce Clause.My classmates and I were told that the Supreme Court had abandoned any effort to limit national power under the Constitution after 1937, and -not surprisinglylegal scholars had largely abandoned the subject as well.In the intervening two decades since my 2L year, however, federalism returned to the Supreme Court's 1 2 docket in landmark cases like United States v. Lopez, Seminole Tribe v. Florida, and Printz v. United States. 3 Likewise, the end of reliable Democratic dominance in Congress and the presidency of George W. Bush shook liberals' instinctive preference for national power, at the same time that a host of new issues emerged gay marriage, global warming on which at least some states seemed more progressive than the national government.It is hardly surprising that federalism has made it back onto the legal academy's teaching and research agenda.We have thus experienced not one "Federalist Revival," but three: judicial, political, and intellectual.The three books that form the subject of this review provide ample evidence of this third revival.Alison LaCroix's The Ideological Origins of American Federalism 4 challenges the conventional wisdom that our federalism dates * Alston & Bird Professor, Duke Law School.I am grateful to Mark Graber, Sandy Levinson,