Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science
Disaggregating Terrorist Offenders: Implications for Research and Practice
See on the mapAbstract
Far-right–inspired violence in the United States is on the rise (Perliger, 2013), and there is a growing realization within policy circles of the increasing threat from so-called “lone wolf” terrorists of different ideological hues (Simon, 2013). A more in-depth understanding of individual offenders and their behaviors (both antecedent and offense-commission) is therefore of great importance not only to the academic literature but also for practitioners tasked with countering the problem. The need for such research is also driven by the fact that a preponderance of studies have focused on violent Islamist organizations for more than a decade. Given the nature of the threat presented by al-Qaeda, this is understandable, but a side effect is that our understanding of the nature of far-right–inspired homicide lags behind our understanding of the behaviors associated with analogous movements. Recognizing these features of the existing literature and the current security environment, Gruenewald, Chermak, and Freilich (2013, this issue) provide an empirical assessment of the behavioral underpinnings of far-right–inspired homicide offenders and compare group-based offenders with lone offenders. Gruenewald et al. (2013) test 23 hypotheses, each of which is derived from a careful examination of the existing literature. Using inferential statistics, they find several significant differences between lone and group offenders. For example, the bivariate analysis suggests that compared with group offenders, far-right lone offenders are statistically more likely to be unmarried, have experience of the military, live alone, use firearms, select government targets, kill more people, and die in the commission of their offense. The multivariate analysis also suggests that age and mental illness also significantly distinguish lone offenders from group offenders (e.g., lone offenders are typically older and more likely to have a history of mental illness). For the remainder of this essay, we consider the salient issues in the available relevant literature in relation to Gruenewald et al.'s (2013) study by identifying and discussing specific and actionable next policy and research steps, as well as this study's potential impact on the current state of knowledge. Reviews of the terrorism research literature have regularly highlighted the paucity of original data that inform analyses (Schmid and Jongman, 1988; Silke, 2001, 2004). In the most recent review of the literature, Silke (2013: 34) noted: “[O]ne feels that a great deal more needs to be done before research is consistently building on past work rather than rehashing old data.” Although the use of inferential statistical methods is certainly on the rise with relation to terrorism research, these studies typically tend to be based on terrorist events rather than on the individual offenders. This is largely because of the data available from the Global Terrorism Database. More recently however, there have been a handful of large-N studies of terrorist group membership that primarily use descriptive statistics (Gill and Horgan, in press; Horgan and Morrison, 2011; Magouirk, Atran, and Sageman, 2008; Reinares, 2004; Sageman, 2004). Gruenewald et al.'s (2013) article is a major next step in the study of the individual terrorist. Their development of the U.S. Extremist Crime Database (ECDB) provides a solid empirical basis from which inferential statistical approaches to the study of extremists and most importantly extremist behavior can be conducted. Gruenewald et al.'s (2013) study highlights significant behavioral and personal differences between far-right–inspired lone and group offenders. Although some of these differences were expected based on their survey of research on lone-actor terrorism, they neglected to mention that a few studies of different crimes have found broadly similar results. For example, Alarid, Buron, and Hochstetler's (2009) study of robberies showed that group offenders we