arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Law

Considering the Who, What, When, Where and How of Measuring Dilution

Jacob H. Jacoby

· Santa Clara computer and high-technology law journal

See on the map

Abstract

Abstract The Trademark Dilution Revision Act of 2006 extended cause of action for trademark dilution, clarifying that dilution may occur by blurring and tarnishment. However, certain considerations must necessarily be taken into account when measuring dilution. This paper considers factors related to measuring trademark dilution. Specifically, this article considers who, what, when, where, and how of measuring dilution. I. INTRODUCTION This paper considers who, what, when, where and how of measuring dilution in light of Trademark Dilution Revision Act (TDRA) of 2006. (1) As such, it amplifies upon an earlier article that outlines cognitive psychological foundations for legal theory of dilution. (2) The TDRA identifies two forms of dilution that can occur with respect to marks--dilution by blurring and dilution by tarnishment. (3) According to TDRA, dilution by blurring is association arising from similarity between a mark or trade name and a mark that impairs distinctiveness of mark, while dilution by tarnishment is association arising from similarity between a mark or trade name and a mark that harms reputation of mark. (4) Why measure dilution? The definitive answer to this question was provided by U.S. Supreme Court in Moseley v. V Secret Catalog, Inc.: Whatever difficulties of proof may be entailed, they are not an acceptable reason for dispensing with proof of an essential element of a statutory violation. The evidence in present record is not sufficient to support summary judgment on dilution count. (5) Thus, whether circumstantial or direct, evidence rather than argument or speculation is essential when seeking to prove dilution. The definitions supplied by TDRA are only first step. Also required are approaches for measuring alleged dilution that are legally persuasive and consistent while also being scientifically valid and reliable. To that end, this paper discusses various measurement considerations, illustrating some using actual case studies. II. WHO? Whose state of mind needs to be measured? When alluding to its history in law, [t]he seminal discussion of dilution is found in Frank Schechter's 1927 law review article. (6) Schechter defined dilution as the gradual whittling away or dispersion of identity and hold upon public's mind of mark or name by its use upon noncompeting goods. (7) Thus, from inception, dilution has been viewed as a psychological phenomenon--that is, something that takes place in minds of consumers. (8) drafting TDRA, Congress followed suit, defining a mark as famous if it is widely recognized by of United States. (9) contrast to Federal Trademark Dilution Act (FTDA) of 1996 which it replaced, TDRA precludes niche that is, protection of marks that are only among a sub population of public. (10) Yet, based upon considering its language, it is not entirely clear to this observer that TDRA precludes certain forms of niche fame. Consider, first, fact that TDRA states: In determining whether a mark possesses requisite degree of recognition [fame], court may consider ... ... geographic reach of advertising ... [and the] geographic extent of sale of goods or services. (11) Why does TDRA make two such references to geographical limits if fame could only be determined by testing consumers across entire United States? By specifying that, in determining fame, the court may consider ... [the] geographic extent of sale of goods or TDRA appears to leave open possibility that fame need not be nationwide (12) Consider also TDRA's use of phrase general of United States. Since each and every one of us is a consumer (13) of products and services, term consuming public is redundant with general public. …

More like this