arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Education

Project Summit: A Cooperative Effort to Effect Teacher Change.

Jacqueline Parten Gerla, Brenda Gilliam, Gary L. Wright

See on the map

Abstract

How often have teachers at all levels sat through hours of staff development while uninvolved and inattentive to the process? How often have college faculty, consultants, and curriculum coordinators questioned the effectiveness of their staff development presentations to educators? Teacher change, the desired result of most staff development programs in education, is often as elusive as the proverbial bird in the bush. Administrators frequently introduce new programs to their staff, yet few manage to grab the hearts and minds of participating teachers. Unless teachers see how a new methodology helps their students, there is little chance for its adoption. Recognizing teachers' typical attitudes toward staff development, an elementary administrator of a large school district in the Southwest established a partnership with the authors of this article and their university students. The purpose of the partnership was to implement a model staff development program that would result in improvement of teachers' skills in teaching literacy and effect improvement in children's developing literacy. Literature Review Research lists many reasons why teachers fail to endorse staff development programs (Gaffney & Anderson). Rationale for teachers' lack of implementation of research-based practices include: 1. Insufficient financial resources, personnel or time (Baumann & Duffy-Hester, 2000; Gallagher, 1998) 2. Weak leadership coupled with insufficient systematic support (Fullen, 1993) 3. Inadequacy of teacher knowledge and skills (Man, Spaulding, Callahan, & McKinzie, 1998) 4. Lack of effort resulting from belief that the innovation is only a passing trend (Slavin, 1989) 5. Inadequate implementation of the procedures (Gallagher, 1998) 6. Lack of access to and knowledge of research findings (Kennedy, 1997) 7. Problems with dissemination of the research (Gallagher, 1998) Chall (1996) expressed concern that research has had little influence on practice. Baumann and Duffy-Hester (2000) suggested that teacher researchers have struggled with methodological issues of selecting, adapting, and creating procedures that accommodate change. Thus, there appears to be a multiplicity of reasons for ineffectual staff development. Nevertheless, the professional literature is not all bleak. Most studies of literacy intervention differ in the extent to which they pursue change in actual practice. Pigott and Barr (2000) argue that development of evaluation and research methods in literacy, when carefully grounded in both literacy theory and classroom practice, can influence theory, practice, and policy. Patton (1997) emphasized the importance of collaboration of participants at differing levels throughout the research. Gaffney and Anderson's (2000) review of reading research revealed that reading and special education practices have been influenced by both qualitative and quantitative research. In an attempt to institute positive changes in teachers' instructional reading behaviors, the authors of this article entered into a collaborative venture with personnel of a large public school. The collaborative venture produced a comprehensive model for staff development that would be implemented utilizing a literacy consultant trained in a balanced literacy approach, university faculty, university students, public school elementary faculty, and public school children in grades two through five. In designing the model, the partners attempted to address and alleviate problems with staff development and teachers' resistance to change noted in the literature (Baumann & Duffy-Hester, 2000; Fullen, 1993; Gallagher, 1998; Kennedy, 1997; Man, Spaulding et al., 1998). Staff Development Model Personnel from an area independent school district and faculty in reading and special education from a mid-size university participated in a grant funded by the state education agency to promote literacy. …

More like this