arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Urban Studies

Governance and development planning: a case study of urban low cost housing in Sarawak, Malaysia

Mohammad Tazuddin, Intan Rahmah

See on the map

Abstract

Despite governments in Malaysia at both Federal and State levels agreeing to give high priority to low cost housing (LCH) for the urban poor, many major issues and concerns remain unresolved. These are manifested in the continued existence of illegal squatters, unsatisfactory delivery of affordable houses, substandard quality, rising costs and so on. There is also the lack of culturally appropriate amenities, social maladies, high rate of crimes and juvenile delinquency at low cost housing projects. In addition, the LCH projects are by and large poorly maintained. There are problems of planning and implementation such as coordination issues between Federal and State agencies. The situation is possibly exacerbated by the governance issues involved in implementing the LCH programme. Thus more attention is needed to make LCH initiatives respond better to the four key pillars of LCH policy of: accessibility, affordability, adequacy and quality. However, in Malaysia, very little holistic research has been conducted to examine the success or failure of governance and development planning (regarding low cost housing) in peripheral states such as Sarawak. To evaluate the effectiveness of public policy in relation to LCH, this research, by analysing the views of stakeholders, examines how neglected agendas of citizen engagement and social sustainability in provision of urban LCH affect the people in these areas. Utilizing qualitative case study methodology, 87 interviews were conducted with residents living in low cost housing in Sarawak (25), and with aspirants of the low cost housing who are squatters (23). Interviews were also conducted with 17 government officials, five politicians, three private housing developers, as well as 14 resettlers. In addition, seven focus group discussions were also held at each of the three low cost housing areas, another two at resettlement areas and two at squatter areas. The research highlights the relationship between urban low cost housing, development planning and participatory governance in Malaysia by analysing three main schemes used to provide urban low cost housing (LCH). These include: house and land for sale projects, flats for rental projects and resettlement schemes for squatter areas (aspirants of LCH) in the city of Kuching, Sarawak. The results indicate that in spite of some successes, LCH programmes in Sarawak have consistently failed to bridge the gap between policy expectations and outcomes. It was found that deficits of governance stymie equitability in resource allocation and distribution systems, to the extent that these arrangements form part of a value system of public officials. By supporting utopian ideals of participatory governance (PG) and by drawing lessons from international best practices, the thesis argues that if Malaysia, and its states like Sarawak, is to become truly democratic with comprehensive equity and social justice, it will need to establish a governance arrangement that is more decentralised, participatory and engaging. It also determines that a participatory public governance arrangement will enhance the capacity of the Malaysian government to make development planning (including LCH planning) more transparent, accountable, equitable and sustainable in Malaysia and Sarawak. It is also argued that decentralisation alone will not be able to solve all the problems associated with deficits of governance in LCH provision. Despite the many types of institutions and mechanisms that have been put in place at the state, divisional, district, and community levels in Sarawak, many sustained issues such as accountability, transparency, restricted citizen activism and poor civic engagement continue to affect development outcomes. The capacity and empowerment of citizens at all levels of decision-making is essential in ensuring that the various challenges in Malaysia and Sarawak regarding LCH can be tackled in an effective and sustainable manner. Hence, the institutiona

More like this