arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science

Not a Desktop, Not a Metaphor. (Metaphors in Action)

Raymond Gozzi

· ETC.: A Review of General Semantics

See on the map

Abstract

FOR YEARS we have heard of the It is the basis for the graphical user interface, or gui, between computers and users. The has a colorful history. It was invented at Xerox Parc, but the Xerox corporation never marketed it. The idea was appropriated by Apple and successfully adapted and marketed in the Macintosh format. The idea was also borrowed by Microsoft, for their Windows Operating system. But I have been puzzled for a long time about this supposed metaphor. A asserts a structural similarity between two domains normally thought to be separate. The asserts that the computer screen is like a But of course it isn't. My point is that the metaphor is not a desktop, and not a metaphor. Let me start with the My real desk is much messier than my computer screen. For example, on the left I have a pile of papers that consists of memos from administration on various topics, other items from my mail, salted with a few interesting magazines or printouts of articles that I want to read when I get the time. This pile on the left also contains a book or two. The pile grows during the year, and then suddenly shrinks dramatically as I go through it and discard or its contents. Now this is actually quite efficient, I have a good sense of what is in there and can usually find what I am looking for pretty quickly. But it is nothing like the neat file folders on the computer screen. The computer screen has nothing like intuitive pile of stuff on it. On my real desk, I do have some real folders. But these do not spring open when I touch them and present me with an alphabetized table of contents. Instead I have to rummage around inside them and hope I put the right paper in there last time I used the file. So when you start looking carefully at your real desktop, you realize just how different it is from the computer interface called a desktop. So can we say that the interface is a for a real desktop? I don't think so. It is more accurate to say that the gui is an ensemble of images on a screen. These images have metaphorical names, such as files, folders, icons, menus, wastebasket, windows. In each case we could say that the metaphorical name of the image is more or less appropriate for its linked contents, although some people have become quite upset with the trash icon on the Macintosh being used for ejecting discs, for this violates the of the wastebasket. But my point is that the ensemble as a whole does not add up to a Further, as Cooper (1995) points out, much of what we do on the desktop gui is really not metaphorical at all. There is nothing in the real world to correspond to the window close boxes, or clicking and dragging. Cooper calls these idioms, because we simply learn them by doing them. This is a different for what we do with the computer interface, using idiomatic figures of speech as the vehicle of the metaphor. An idiomatic expression like chew the fat must simply be learned. It refers to talking with someone, not chewing or eating fatty foods. Once we know the idiom it is easy and automatic to use. Similarly, Cooper notes that using a scroilbar on a gui interface is just something we learn. It is not like anything we do on a But once we learn the scrolibar, it seems natural and we do it without thinking twice. …

More like this